JournalReviewer 

Submit Review Report.

Below you can submit a report for a review process of a manuscript you (co-)authored. Please make sure that all authors of your submission agree to reporting to JournalReviewer. This also prevents reports by multiple authors of the same manuscript.

JournalReviewer is moderated. All reports will be checked by two independent reviewers for completeness and appropriateness of language before they get published and aggregated.

Your Information.

Per default, the review reports are all anonymous. If you prefer, however, you can chose to publish the report under your name and email address.
Your name: (optional)
Your email address: (optional)

Select Journal.

Please enter the journal you submitted to in the text field below. When you begin to type a few letters of the journal name, a list of possible journals will appear so that you can choose the journal you are referencing.

If you cannot find the journal in the list, it has not been added to our database yet, and you cannot submit reports for it at the moment. However, you can suggest adding the journal to our database here.

Submission Status.

Please indicate the current status of the review process for your submission at the journal you have selected. If the review process has been completed and you have received a final editorial decision on your manuscript, you will be able to evaluate each round of reviews separately below.

Should the review process still be ongoing, you can evaluate all rounds that have been finished so far, and return in the future to report the final reviews and decision. For this, however, it is required to enter a valid email address below.
This email address is just for the purpose of providing you with a unique link to edit your report later on when a final editorial decision has been made. It will not be published with your report. Should you want to be identifiable, please enter your information in the fields above.

I received at least one round of reviews, and the current process for my submission is...
finished, with final editorial decision (accept, revise & resubmit, or reject)
ongoing, still under consideration (further review rounds to come) I did NOT receive any reviews. The editorial decision was a...
desk reject (no reviews)

Reviews.

How many rounds of reviews have there been?
Currently: 1 review round(s)

Review Round 1.

Please indicate when you submitted the manuscript to the journal, and when you received the first round of reviews. The difference between submission and return date will be aggregated for each journal so that individual reports cannot be identified by submission dates.
1. Your initial submission
2. Returned reviews
 


(click here to add and remove reviewers for this round)
Below you can rate the reviews and editorial decision you received for your initial submission (round 1). You can paste the full text of each review into the textbox for an automatic word count. The text will not be stored in our database! By checking the box below the text field after pasting the review, the word count will be finalized and the text deleted.
If the reviews are not available to you anymore, but you still want to submit a report, leave the field enmpty and check the box to finalize the word count anyway.
 
Finalize Word Count & Delete Text

Review 1(Word Count 0)

 
low high
1 2 3 4 5 n/a
Knowledge
Helpfulness
Fairness
Overall quality
 
Finalize Word Count & Delete Text

Editor's Comments(Word Count 0)

 
low high
1 2 3 4 5 n/a
Helpfulness
Fairness
Plausibility of Decision
Overall quality
 
 

Your Review Report

Overall evaluation.

Please indicate the overall quality of this review process.

low12345high

Would you submit to this journal again?

unlikely12345likely

Would you recommend a colleague submitting to this journal?

not at all12345fully

Your Comments.

Below you can add comments on the review process or the reviewers' and editors' decisions.

(You have 5000 characters left.)




Suggest Journal

Missing a journal in our database? Suggest adding it below!